Friday, January 15, 2016

HF at Greers - "Correcting the Traditional Nativity Story"

On our regular second Saturday meeting (January 9), our HF took a break from studying Acts and asked Bryant to give us a "replay" of his "Archaeological/Historical View of the Nativity" presentation, as it had been many years since he did it for us, back when John and Cindy were our HF leaders (I can still hear Cindy: "You ruined my nativity scene!").

This is how his Nativity set-up started...

This is how it ended.

In summary - the manger scene corrections:
  • There was no star at the manger
  • There was no angel at the manger
  • The wise men only arrived about two years later and saw the Child (not Baby) at the house - not a stable, not by a manger. So... move the angel, move the star, move the Wise Men, move the animals (that one is explained below).
In the story of the Nativity:
  • The Bible doesn't say Mary and Elizabeth were cousins; Elizabeth is identified as "a relative"
  • The traditional rendering of Mary riding a donkey has no biblical basis. Since the offering for her purification was the one given by people of scarce means, it's most likely they would not have been able to afford a donkey.
  • There is no innkeeper mentioned anywhere
  • The word translated as "inn" is the same Greek word later used for "upper room" - "kataluna" in English script. That was usually a room reserved for guests in the upper level of the house; the lower level was usually reserved for animals. With the census, the upper room evidently was already occupied, so the people in the house did the best they could. And the references to "smelly stable" is most likely inaccurate as well. In the traditional culture of hospitality of that day, they would have done their best to clean up the place.
  • So there probably were NO animals surrounding the manger.
  • It doesn't say that the three wise men went to Bethlehem after consulting Herod; the Bible just says that after leaving Herod's palace, "they saw the star and rejoiced" and it led them to where the Child was. Since another Gospel states that after Mary's purification they went to Nazareth, it could just as well be that the star led the wise men to Nazareth, not Bethlehem (but Herod would not have known that).
  • And as beautiful as the carol is, "In the bleak midwinter" is not accurate, either; the shepherds would not have been out in the field with the sheep, had it been winter. 
  • There were some other items, related to chronology, but too involved to list here.
It was a very interesting presentation...

After Bryant's presentation, Keith showed a short video clip sent by the Dagers, our group's "adopted missionaries" for intercession. It was a greeting from the director of the Pal*stinian Bible Society (the Dagers minister on that side of the world); it was encouraging and challenging. 

The Greers' place was beautifully decorated - a feast for the eyes - so I just had to get some photos. It started on their porch, with this duck procession greeting us.

















Loved her Byer's Choice carolers - she had several. But there's a cat missing in this setup!




No comments:

Post a Comment